Biden Open to Cut Plan Length 10/16 06:32
President Joe Biden says he would prefer to cut the duration of programs in
his big social services and climate change package rather than eliminate some
entirely, as Democrats struggle to win support from moderates by trimming what
had been a $3.5 trillion proposal.
HARTFORD, Conn. (AP) -- President Joe Biden says he would prefer to cut the
duration of programs in his big social services and climate change package
rather than eliminate some entirely, as Democrats struggle to win support from
moderates by trimming what had been a $3.5 trillion proposal.
Biden's comments on Friday, reassuring progressives on what he hopes will be
a landmark piece of his legacy, marked his clearest indication yet on how he
hopes negotiations over the bill will play out. Appearing to side with a
strategy preferred by progressive lawmakers, it marked at least a subtle break
with House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, who has suggested that most Democrats prefer
to focus on establishing a few enduring programs.
He also said there is no deadline for a deal.
"I'm of the view that it's important to establish the principle on a whole
range of issues without guaranteeing to get the whole 10 years," Biden told
reporters before boarding Air Force One to return to Washington from a trip to
Connecticut. "It matters to establish it."
"So what happens is, you pass the principle and you build on it," he added.
"You look back and either it works or it doesn't work."
Pelosi, however, in a Monday note to fellow Democratic lawmakers, said,
"Overwhelmingly, the guidance I am receiving from members is to do fewer things
Biden said Friday that although he expects the package to shrink, "we're
going to come back and get the rest" after it's passed.
"We're not going to get $3.5 trillion. We'll get less than that, but we're
gonna get it. And we're going to come back and get the rest," Biden said during
remarks at a child care center in Connecticut.
Democrats on Capitol Hill are working to reduce the sweeping package to
about $2 trillion in spending, which would be paid for with higher taxes on
corporations and the wealthy. The proposal includes everything from free child
care and community college to dental, vision and hearing aid benefits for
seniors and a number of significant provisions meant to combat climate change.
They're all key items for progressives, but moderates have balked at the
original $3.5 trillion price tag.
One almost certain reduction would be in the proposal for free community
"I doubt whether we will get the entire funding for community colleges but
I'm not going to give up on community colleges as long as I'm president," Biden
said. His wife, Jill, is a professor of English at Northern Virginia Community
With slim margins in the House and the Senate, Democrats have no votes to
spare on the bill. The whittling process has sparked concern from some
The party's internal debate was apparent as Senate Budget Committee Chairman
Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., wrote an opinion column for a West Virginia newspaper
calling out that state's Democratic Sen. Joe Manchin by name for blocking the
domestic package so far.
Sanders named Manchin as one of only two Democratic senators who "remain in
opposition" to the measure, thwarting the unanimous support the party needs in
the 50-50 Senate to approve the still-evolving legislation.
"This is a pivotal moment in modern American history. We now have a historic
opportunity to support the working families of West Virginia, Vermont and the
entire country and create policy which works for all, not just the few,"
Sanders wrote in a piece scheduled to appear in Sunday's Charleston
Manchin shot back in a statement late Friday, saying: "It isn't the first
time an out-of-stater has tried to tell West Virginians what is best for them."
It's highly unusual for a senator to publicly criticize a colleague of the
same party, particularly by wading into the other lawmaker's state.
Manchin has proposed holding the measure's overall 10-year cost to $1.5
trillion and has said he wants to limit some health care initiatives to benefit
only lower-earning people.
Sanders and Manchin stand, respectively, as among the Democrats' most
progressive and conservative senators.
Biden has openly acknowledged the price tag of his package will have to come
down. On Friday, he visited a child development center in Hartford to speak
about a need for investments in child care and other social safety net
programs, arguing they're imperative to keep America competitive in the global
At the center, Biden promoted his proposal to make such care free for
lower-income families, and ensure that families making up to 150% of their
state's median income pay less than 7% of their salaries on child care. It's
part of a massive expansion of the social safety net that Biden has championed
and is aiming to pass with just Democratic votes in Congress.
"Too many folks in Washington still don't realize it isn't enough just to
invest in our physical infrastructure. We also have to invest in our people,"
Biden briefly greeted some of the children at the center's playground, at
one point kneeling to give a child a hug.
The president's sales pitch comes as his Democratic allies have raised
concerns that the American public does not understand the benefits of his
package. There is renewed urgency among Democrats to push it through ahead of
an end-of-month deadline on transportation funding, Biden's upcoming foreign
trip, and a closer-than-anticipated race for Virginia's next governor.
The fate of the legislation, branded "Build Back Better" by Biden, is also
holding up a more than $1 trillion bipartisan infrastructure bill that passed
the Senate this summer. House progressives are balking at supporting that
roads-and-bridges bill until agreement is reached on a path forward for the
social safety net package.
In an interview this week with The Associated Press, Terry McAuliffe, the
Democratic candidate for Virginia governor, criticized Democrats including
Biden over the lack of progress.
"They all got to get their act together and vote," McAuliffe said. Asked
specifically if he was calling out Biden, McAuliffe said, "I put everybody
there." McAuliffe is in a tight race with Republican newcomer Glenn Youngkin in
a state Biden carried by 10 points last fall.
Biden also delivered remarks later at the dedication of the Dodd Center for
Human Rights at the University of Connecticut, which is being renamed to honor
a longtime friend, former Connecticut Sen. Chris Dodd, and Dodd's father, also
a former senator.